Columbia, Missouri
Name | Columbia's Beverage Container Deposit Ordinance |
---|---|
Purpose | To reduce litter |
Enacted | April 1977 |
Implemented | 1982 |
Beverages Covered | Beer, malt, carbonated/mineral waters, soft drinks |
Containers Covered | Unknown |
Amount of Deposit | 5¢ |
Unredeemed Deposits | Unknown |
Handling Fee | None |
Details
Columbia's deposit law was the only municipal container deposit ordinance in the US. It was repealed in April of 2002.
After four previous repeal attempts, the beverage and grocery industry lobby succeeded in convincing the public that the new municipal "blue bag"recycling program should replace the bottle bill. Citizens voted on April 2 , 2002 to repeal the nation's only local bottle bill ordinance.
Repeal supporters, who called themselves the "Yes on Recycling Committee," argued that the deposit ordinance was robbing Columbia's municipal recycling system, better known as the Blue Bag program, of aluminum revenue, and that it costed distributors and retailers exorbitant amounts of money to operate. The Container Recycling Institute (CRI) and Columbians Against Throwaways (CAT) exposed this false claim: an analysis of current container packaging trends and the City of Columbia's budget numbers showed that Columbia taxpayers could expect to pay to more money to recycle millions fewer beverage containers if the deposit ordinance was repealed. Columbians could also expect to see dirtier streets and increased clean up costs as hundreds of thousands of bottles and cans that were previously recycled through the deposit system ended up as litter. The "Yes on Recycling Committee," a front group for the beverage industry, spent an estimated $100,000 trying to convince voters to repeal the deposit ordinance. They placed print, radio, and television ads, mailed flyers to all registered voters in Columbia (three days in a row), and distributed flyers to supermarket customers.
In response to the repeal supporters' bombardment of voters with anti-deposit propaganda, CRI and CAT put out several news releases and placed ads in Columbia's main daily newspaper, the Columbia Daily Tribune, and on local radio.
Press Releases
- Prop.1 Would Increase Cost of City’s ‘Blue Bag’ Curbside Recycling
Container Recycling Institute - March 21, 2002 - Environmental Group Challenges Soft Drink, Beer and Grocery Companies to ‘Come Clean’ on Prop1 Spending
Container Recycling Institute - March 26, 2002 - Beverage and Grocery Spending Key to Repeal of Columbia's Deposit Law
Container Recycling Institute - April 3, 2002
Advertisements
- Trash Talk from the Repeal Advocacy Puppets [PDF, 1.4 Mb]
April 1, 2002 - Deposits: The Common Sense Solution to Litter and Waste [PDF, 1.7 Mb]
March 30, 2002 - The only green
the Deposit Repeal
advocates are interested in [PDF, 1.7 Mb]
March 28, 2002 - Deposits Make Cents!
March 26, 2002 - What is the real impact of repealing Columbia's 5¢ bottle and can deposit law?
March 21, 2002
News Articles
- The deposit vote: Larger implications
Editorial in Columbia Daily Tribune
April 4, 2002 - Five from city council back deposit system
Article in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 31, 2002 - Deposit repeal supporters put ordinance to the test
Article in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 31, 2002 - Businesses promise to fight litter
Article in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 31, 2002 - Staff report refutes that of recycling institute
Article in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 31, 2002 - Chamber favors repeal, so deposit law should stay
Article in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 29, 2002 - Environmentalists say ordinance is sound
Article in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 28, 2002 - Deposit law supporters cry foul
Article in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 26, 2002 - Group pans deposit repeal
Article in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 25, 2002 - Voters revisit returns - Vote No
Open Column in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 24, 2002 - Voters revisit returns - Vote Yes
Open Column in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 24, 2002 - Deposit law costs city, analyst says
Article in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 20, 2002 - Deposit law: The case for repeal
Editorial in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 19, 2002 - Canned Controversy
Article in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 17, 2002 - Deposit law repeal means trashy city
Article in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 12, 2002 - Chamber urges repeal of deposit law
Article in Columbia Daily Tribune
March 9, 2002